ISRAEL: Israir Still Backs Arkia Merger After Cash-Deadline Talks Collapse - Sirkis
TEL AVIV, Israel: Israir chief executive Uri Sirkis says a merger with Arkia is still the right move, after talks collapsed because the airline needed a USD 30 million cash injection within a month, too short a period for a competition review, Globes reported.
TEL AVIV, Israel
- Uri Sirkis, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of Israir Group, has told Globes that a merger with Arkia Israeli Airlines remains the right course, after talks with the carrier's owners collapsed because Arkia needed a cash injection of USD 30 million within a month, a timetable Israir could not meet once a review by the Israel Competition Authority was under way.
- The comments come after businessman Ronen Elad took control of Arkia earlier this week. IAN reported on 16 November that the board approved a deal under which Elad will inject about USD 30 million and hold 82% of the shares, the Nakash group will inject USD 8.5 million and keep 3%, and the employees' holding will fall from 22% to 15%. Globes restated those terms.
The Thursday Sale
- On Thursday, 12 November, Arkia employees declared a labour dispute. Two hours later, Globes reported, they learned from news-site alerts that the Nakash family had signed a sale to an investor group led by Keidan Dahari, Yaron Adiv, and Yariv Lerner, without prior discussion with the employees and without their being party to the move.
- A source involved in the talks on the employees' side told Globes the episode was the kind usually seen only in films, adding that a partner is not presented with a completed deal without first being spoken to.
- The agreement signed at the outset was intended to cut the Nakash family's holding from about 78% to 3% and to dilute the employees' stake almost entirely.
- That evening, representatives of the buyer group arrived at a board meeting. A sharp confrontation developed between employee representatives and Avi Hormoro, the Nakash family's representative, including shouting and pounding on the table, and later with the buyers' representatives. After tempers rose, the Nakash brothers left the room and the meeting broke up, leaving the employees and the intended buyers alone.
- A source familiar with the matter told Globes that the employees concluded the buyers were looking for something else, and that even if terms could have been agreed, the way the first approach was handled did not sit well with them. Beyond the content of a deal, the source said, there is also the manner in which business is conducted.
Three Days To Find Another Buyer
- Despite the clash, the employees were given three days to find an investor who could offer a different structure. IAN reported that the deadline ran until the afternoon of Monday, 16 November. Globes said Arkia needed money quickly, and that a prolonged period of uncertainty would have been dangerous.
- Talks with other investors began an hour after the board meeting and continued, a source for the employees said, in an unbroken loop until Monday afternoon. The source said the employees did not start from scratch: investors approached them, knowing there was a narrow window.
- A further source familiar with the details told Globes that if a transaction had not been completed within a few days, there would have been no way to pay the staff, and day-to-day operations would also have been hurt. People familiar with the matter said the urgent cash was needed for aircraft fuel and salaries.
Why The Israir Talks Failed
- Among those who sounded out the employees was Israir, which is controlled by Rami Levy. Globes had reported about a week earlier that the group was in talks to acquire Arkia, after IAN reported Sirkis's earlier comments on a possible combination.
- Sirkis told Globes that the Nakash family approached Levy and discussed the need to inject USD 30 million immediately, within a month. He said leading accounting firms advised Israir that it would have to begin a lengthy process before the Israel Competition Authority, and that the group could not complete that process in the time required. By then, he said, Arkia would have collapsed.
- A source familiar with the details told Globes that the short timetable, not a fear that the Competition Authority would block a deal, was why Levy stepped back. The same source said Israir and Arkia do not really compete with one another, and that the real competition is with El Al Israel Airlines and its fares.
- Sirkis said the last word on a merger may not have been spoken and that any further move would also depend on the new owner, but that, in his view, it is still right to pursue a combination. He argued that a country of 10 million people should not have six airlines when, he said, all of Europe has fewer than ten, and that keeping Israeli carriers small makes it impossible to compete with large foreign airlines.
Other Suitors And Elad's Offer
- Another name considered by the employees was Ezra Unger, the New York-based ultra-Orthodox businessman who had previously shown interest in Arkia but wanted a structure that would end Saturday flights. IAN reported that bid on 15 November. A source told Globes that, on the employees' forecasts, the airline's finances would have suffered if Saturday flying stopped, and that compensation for staff would also have had to be discussed.
- Ami Cohen, one of the owners of Blue Bird, also offered to come in through an investor group, with a USD 30 million injection, the employees keeping their full holding of about 22%, and Saturday operations continuing. The offer arrived relatively late, and the process had to move quickly. The same source asked why Cohen had only come forward now, given that the company had been up for sale for a year and a half.
- The bid ultimately accepted was from Elad, who had already tried to buy Arkia and had met the Nakash family years ago, including more than a decade earlier. He offered a structure under which the employees would remain shareholders with 15%, together with rights and representation in the company's governing bodies. For the employees, Globes reported, that was a substantial concession from about 22%, but preferable to being diluted almost to zero.
- One employee representative told Globes that Elad said he did not want the staff to go anywhere and wanted them as his partners. The employees, the representative said, were looking for someone who believed in the company's growth and saw the workforce as part of that path.
- About 200 employees stood outside just before the Nakash brothers had to decide on the sale, in part to apply pressure. One employee asked how the brothers could have refused when they saw all of them looking angry.
The Sellers' View
- Joe, Rafi, and Avi Nakash have given Globes their first on-record comments after the sale of control of Arkia to Ronen Elad. The brothers said the family had held the airline for 20 years and had invested tens of millions of dollars in it in recent years alone.
- They admitted mistakes had been made, including Arkia's decision not to hedge jet-fuel prices. Globes said that decision led to a loss of USD 30 million in the first nine months of 2026 and to additional fuel costs of USD 107 million.
- Globes also reported a further misjudgment at the end of the previous decade, when the state replaced Eilat's airport with Ramon Airport and closed Sde Dov in Tel Aviv, moving the flights to Ben Gurion Airport. Arkia, the newspaper said, was unprepared: traffic on the Tel Aviv–Eilat route was cut from about 1 million passengers a year to 400,000–500,000, and the route's share of revenue fell from 50% to about 20%.
- The brothers told Globes they would continue to invest in Israel and intended to list further holdings.
Sources:
Comments ()